I went to find my trusty philosophy the present clear eyes pencil – a wonderful creamy pencil for the inner rim of the eye that makes my eyes seem super big and wide awake – and found that philosophy doesn’t make it anymore! So, I went looking on the philosophy website (pouting slightly at the loss of my perfect pencil), I found they have a section that lists products that were recently discontinued here.
From there, you may want to contact philosophy through their website to see if there is any way to get a hold of your product, or they may be able to recommend a similar product within their own line.